![]() |
| Bills quarterback Frank Reich completed 21 of 37 passes for 214 yards and threw two touchdown passes in his first NFL start. |
Quarterback Frank Reich is known for directing two of the greatest comeback wins in the history of football.
In 1984, Reich came off the bench to relieve a struggling Stan Gelbaugh to start the second half of the Maryland Terrapins' game against the Miami Hurricanes where he led the Terps to six straight scoring drives as Maryland overcame a 31-0 halftime deficit to shock the Hurricanes 42-40 in what was at the time the largest comeback in college football history.
Eight years later while filling in a for injured Jim Kelly, Reich led the Buffalo Bills to the greatest comeback in NFL playoff history as Buffalo overcame a 35-3 deficit to knock off the Houston Oilers 41-38 in overtime of their 1992 AFC Wild Card game.
But there is a lesser known comeback or miracle Reich was at the helm of when he made his first career NFL start in the Buffalo Bills' week 6 game with the Los Angeles Rams.
Having been selected in the third round of the 1985 NFL draft, Reich served as the backup quarterback to Vince Ferragamo for the 1985 season and then Kelly who took over as the Bills' starting quarterback in 1986 after a two-year stint in the USFL.
In his first four seasons, Reich had attempted only 20 passes as the Bills rose from the one of the worst teams in the NFL to an appearance in the 1988 AFC Championship Game against the Cincinnati Bengals which they lost 21-10.
The Bills entered the 1989 season as Super Bowl contenders but several disputes amongst the Bills roster which included running back Thurman Thomas, wide receiver Andre Reed and defensive end Bruce Smith led to those in the media to nickname the Bills the "Bickering Bills".
In week 5 against the Indianapolis Colts, Kelly separated his left shoulder after a hit by Indianapolis Colts defensive end Jon Hand, in which Kelly blamed right tackle Howard Ballard for missing the block, as Reich would come in to 11 of 19 passes for 171 yards and threw his first career touchdown pass in a 37-14 loss to the Colts which dropped the Bills to 3-2.
With Kelly out for the next month, Reich would assumed the reins as the Bills' starting quarterback as Reich's first start would come in front of a nationwide audience on Monday Night Football.
The Bills' opponent for this week were the Los Angeles Rams, who were off to a 5-0 start to the season which included a 13-12 over the defending Super Bowl champion San Francisco 49ers in San Francisco.
The biggest reason for the Rams' hot start was their offense which was led by quarterback Jim Everett and included former Bills running back Greg Bell and the wide receiver tandem of Willie "Flipper" Anderson and Henry Ellard as the offense averaged 28.4 points and 395.4 yards per game in the first five games of the season.
With their high-powered offense going up against a Buffalo defense that was minus three starters and a backup quarterback making his first career NFL start, the Rams were expected to came out of western New York with a 6-0 record.
After the Rams punted on their opening possession of the game, the Bills got the ball at their eight-yard-line where Reich completed his first pass of the game, a five-yard screen pass to Thomas on the first play of the drive.
Thomas would then reel off a 38-yard run to get the Bills into Los Angeles territory until Reich was intercepted by Rams cornerback Jerry Gray on a pass intended for Buffalo wide receiver Flip Johnson as the Rams would take over at the Bills' 46-yard-line.
It looked like the Bills would get the ball back as they held the Rams to a three-and-out but Mickey Sutton would muff the ensuing punt as LA linebacker Richard Brown would make the recovery to give the Rams a golden opportunity to get on the scoreboard as they begin their next possession at the Buffalo 16-yard-line.
A two-yard run by Bell and an incomplete pass would set up 3rd & 8 when Everett found running back Buford McGee over the middle for a 10-yard completion to give Los Angeles a 1st & goal at the Bills' four-yard-line as Bell would run for one yard to set up 2nd & goal when Everett connected with McGee again, this time for the three-yard touchdown to give the Rams a 7-0 lead with 5:02 left in the first quarter.
The two teams would trade punts as the game moved into the second quarter when on a 2nd & 23 from the Bills 41-yard-line, Everett threw deep for Ellard, only to have the pass intercepted by Buffalo free safety Mark Kelso, whose 33-yard return gave the Bills the ball at the Rams' 47-yard-line.
However, the Bills could not convert the turnover into points as they would go three-and-out to punt the ball back to the Rams, but would get another chance later in the second quarter when Bell fumbled the football after a hit by Bills defensive end Art Still as defensive tackle Jeff Wright would recover the fumble at the Los Angeles 20-yard-line.
While the Bills' offense would not gain a yard on their next drive, they would get some points as Scott Norwood would come on to kick a 38-yard field goal to cut the Rams' lead to 7-3 with 4:10 left in the second quarter.
Following a Los Angeles three-and-out, the Bills got the ball back at the Rams' 49-yard-line as Reich completed two passes to Reed for 15 yards while Thomas ran for six yards to set up another Norwood field goal, this one from 48 yards out, which barely glazed the crossbar to trim the deficit to one point at 7-6 with 56 seconds left before halftime.
![]() |
| Bills running back Thurman Thomas had 24 carries for 105 yards and caught nine passes for 67 yards |
Buffalo got the ball to start the second half only to give the ball right back to the Rams on the first play from scrimmage when Thomas would lose the football at the end of a six-yard run as Rams defensive back Michael Stewart would make the recovery to give Los Angeles an opportunity to extend their lead as they took over possession at the Bills' 33-yard-line.
But a sack by Smith for a five-yard loss would knock the Rams out of field goal range and force them to punt the ball back to the Bills as the two teams would trade punts until the Rams would put together their best drive of the game later in the third quarter.
Starting at their 37-yard-line, Everett would complete a seven-yard pass to tight end Pete Holohan which was followed by two runs by Bell for five yards to pick up a Rams 1st down at the LA 49-yard-line.
Everett would then connect with Ellard for 24 yards and again for 19 yards to move Los Angeles to the Buffalo eight-yard-line when the Rams averted disaster when Bell fumbled the football after a hit by Wright as Everett would fall on the football after a nine-yard loss that pushed the Rams back to the Bills' 17-yard-line.
Two incomplete passes later, the Rams would settle for a 34-yard field goal by Mike Lansford to extend their lead back to four points at 10-6 with 2:56 to go in the third quarter.
The Bills would get the ball back at their 25-yard-line as Thomas would carry the ball four times for 20 yards plus catch a 13-yard pass from Reich on a 12-play, 52-yard drive that culminated with a 40-yard field goal by Norwood make it a one-point game once again at 10-9 in favor of the Rams just 51 seconds into the fourth quarter.
The Rams would begin their ensuing possession at their 21-yard-line as Everett would complete two passes to Ellard for 27 yards to move Los Angeles to the Buffalo 41-yard-line when on 3rd & 13, Everett tried to connect with Ellard again on a pass that fell incomplete but drew a 25-yard pass interference penalty on Sutton to give the Rams a 1st down at the Bills' 16-yard-line.
However, the Rams would lose three yards on the next three plays to force Los Angeles to settle for a 36-yard field goal by Lansford to increase the LA lead to 13-9 with 9:01 to in the fourth quarter.
Reich, who had completed 11 of 26 passes for only 78 yards, would have his longest completion on the opening play of the Bills' next drive as he hit Reed for a 49-yard pass to move the Bills into Rams territory at the Los Angeles 39-yard-line.
It looked like the Rams defense was going to force a punt as they would sack Reich on 3rd & 8 only to have defensive back Anthony Newman get called for a holding penalty to give the Bills a fresh set of downs at the Los Angeles 32-yard-line.
Three straight running plays for 11 yards would move Buffalo to the LA 21-yard-line when Reich found Reed again, this time for 15 yards to give the Bills a 1st & goal at the six-yard-line.
After a five-yard run by Larry Killebrew and a Thomas run that went nowhere, Reich would throw the second touchdown pass of his NFL career, a one-yard toss to Thomas to give the Bills their first lead of the game at 16-13 with 2:23 left in regulation.
The Rams would take over at their 26-yard-line with a chance to drive at least a game-tying field goal or a go-ahead touchdown but after a six-yard scramble by Everett to start the drive, the quarterback would throw three straight incomplete passes to force a turnover on downs and give the Bills the ball at the Los Angeles 32-yard-line with 1:53 left on the clock.
With all three timeouts left, the Rams holped to stop the Bills from picking up a 1st down as two straight running plays for two yards would set up a crucial 3rd & 8 when Thomas appeared to pick up the 1st down, only for Rams linebacker Mel Owens to strip Thomas of the football, causing a fumble that was recovered by Stewart to give Los Angeles the ball at their 22-yard-line with 1:33 left in the game.
It would take the Rams just one play to get into the end zone as Everett threw a pass over the middle for Anderson, who made the catch around midfield and outran the rest of the Buffalo defense for a shocking 78-yard touchdown to give Los Angeles a 20-16 lead with 82 seconds left to play.
A squib kick plus a 18-yard return on the ensuing kickoff would give the Bills good field position for their next drive which would begin at their 36-yard-line as Buffalo had 1:17 left on the clock and all three timeouts in their pocket as Buffalo needed a touchdown to win the game.
The Bills averted disaster to start the drive as Reich completed a six-yard pass to Reed, who fumbled the football after a hit by Rams linebacker Mike Wilcher as center Kent Hull would recover the fumble at the Buffalo 42-yard-line but more importantly keep the drive going.
Reich would then complete a three-yard pass to Thomas to set up 3rd & 1 which became 3rd & 6 after a false start penalty on Bills left tackle Will Wolford, when Reich found Thomas for 17 yards to give Buffalo a 1st down at the Los Angeles 43-yard-line as Buffalo called timeout with 40 seconds to go.
Reich would then hit Thomas for six yard and then again for 15 yards for a fresh set of downs at the Rams' 22-yard-line as the Bills spent their second timeout with 26 seconds to go.
A 14-yard pass to Harmon, who was knocked out of bounds at the Rams' eight-yard-line, would set up a 1st & goal with 20 seconds to go when Reich found Reed on a slant pass, who was able to outmuscle Rams cornerback LeRoy Irvin to cross the plane with the ball for the touchdown with 16 seconds to go and give the Bills a 23-20 lead.
The Rams would get one last chance at a miracle as Everett would threw a Hail Mary from his 40-yard-line only for it to fall incomplete as time expired with the Bills on top 23-20 to hand the Rams their first loss of the 1989 season.
The loss to the Bills would begin a four-game losing streak for the Rams as they would go on to finish the season with a 11-5 record which included a 23-20 overtime win over the New Orleans Saints where Anderson set the all-time mark for most receiving yards in a game with 336(To read about that game click on the link highlighted here: https://oldschoolsportsblog.blogspot.com/2018/10/nfl-old-school-game-of-week-flipper.html)to earn a playoff spot as a Wild Card team as Los Angeles would upset the Philadelphia Eagles 21-17 in the Wild Card round, then knock off the New York Giants 19-13 in overtime of their divisional playoff game(To read about that game, click on the link highlighted here: https://oldschoolsportsblog.blogspot.com/2021/10/nfl-old-school-game-of-week-flippers.html)as the Rams would fall to the 49ers 30-3 in the NFC Championship Game.
Reich would remain the Bills' starter for the next two games, which they both won to improve to 6-2, before Kelly returned from injury as the Bills would struggle for the second half of the season as they would lose five of their final eight games to finish the season with a 9-7 record but still good enough to win the AFC East division.
The Bills would be eliminated by the Cleveland Browns 34-30 in their AFC divisional playoff to end their 1989 season before going on their four-year run as AFC Champions as they would play in the next four Super Bowls but failing to capture the Lombardi Trophy in each of their four Super Bowl appearances.
Reich would remain with the Bills through the next five seasons, starting in seven games across that span, including the legendary comeback against the Oilers in the 1992 playoffs, before bouncing around the league as he played for three different teams over the next four seasons before retiring after the 1998 NFL season.







.jpg)












